Image via Eastern Michigan Athletics

First Down: From 3-0 to 3-3 in MAC play

This ain’t it.

Whatever happened last week is now, definitively, a new low for Eastern Michigan’s football program under Chris Creighton.

Eastern Michigan (4-6, 3-3 MAC) was always in search of new heights under Creighton’s leadership, and he’s gotten the team to feel a few of them. Three wins over Big Ten schools, then another Power-level win over Arizona State. The program’s first bowl victory in 35 years. One of the best defensive players in the NFL today played for EMU and Creighton, and was even a commit to the team before its turnaround years.

Still, EMU has failed to reach its one goal it always sets out for. EMU still hasn’t made it to the MAC championship game. After three straight league wins over Sacramento State, UMass, and Akron, EMU lost to Toledo, at Ohio, and, most recently, versus Central Michigan at Ford Field.

That 35-7 CMU loss, with a new trophy on the line and on a Wednesday night for the nation to see, was completely disheartening.

I’d go so far as to say it’s the team’s most-disappointing loss on Creighton’s record (65-89) since Toledo 2022.

While the 2024 Toledo loss, decided by a failed 2-point conversion at the end of the game, was a heartbreaker, the 3-point loss in 2022 ultimately kept EMU from winning the old MAC West division outright and from going to the MAC championship game for the first time.

EMU just looked flat and uncompetitive against its in-state rival in Detroit. CMU’s front five blockers dominated the line of scrimmage all night long (no negative run plays), and EMU’s offense gained only one first down through its first six possessions (five punts, one interception).

That game was so bad it deserves a nickname. I’ll lead things off. That, my friends, was the Detroit Dumpster Fire of 2026.

Yes, the Toledo nightmare on homecoming was a violent wreck. Toledo also has the best defensive player in the league, and he played like an ace that day (as did the entire Rocket offense). The loss at Ohio largely stunk offensively, but EMU was still just four yards away from throwing a rock in the league standings.

CMU isn’t as good as Toledo or Ohio. Not even close. CMU was out some of their best players (injuries, WR Langston Lewis disciplined), and their (/checks notes) fourth-string running back had the game of his life. Nick Woodford entered the game with 135 yards rushed on the year, and he had 123 with a trio of touchdowns scored in the Motor City.

EMU needed to make the most of its opportunity in Detroit last week, and it just didn’t do that. Instead of a midweek thriller, it played a boring football game on ESPN2.

Second Down: What would it cost to make a change?

Here’s the question everybody wants to know. Will any changes – any at all – be made upstairs after last week’s stinker?

Fair question! EMU is, after all, labeled as an FBS football program. It’s showbiz, baby. And as college football continues to evolve into the 24-team playoff era, every week over the past few years has felt like teams everywhere are all actively auditioning for their positions in the sport’s future.

But does EMU actually see itself playing its way into a playoff one day? Or is EMU privately considering a bump down to FCS?

Here’s a pretty straightforward one EMU probably needs to answer first, and it’s one I’m sure you’ve heard in interviews before.

Where does EMU see itself in 10 years?

If EMU envisions itself as a super duper serious football program that finally rose to be the MAC’s best-in-class, it’ll have to accept that the status quo just isn’t cutting it.

Chris Creighton

I don’t have any intel. I’ve just been observing this athletic department for some time. I don’t think EMU’s decision-makers necessarily want to boot Creighton, especially for football reasons. Creighton has never embarrassed the school in his 13 years as a coach.

He’s the best modern-day coach the school has ever had. He raised the floor of a program that was once the laughingstock of FBS football.

Creighton deserves a lot of credit for taking on one of the hardest and least-considered jobs in America and molding a very respectable football program out of it. He did one of the hardest things in college football, which is rebuilding a bad football program into a good one. Creighton just hasn’t had a group in his 13 years that was transcendent.

The problem is that he hasn’t given EMU a banner year to celebrate.

  • 2014: 2-10 overall (1-7 MAC)

  • 2015: 1-11 (0-8 MAC)

  • 2016: 7-6 (4-4 MAC), L Bahamas Bowl

  • 2017: 5-7 (3-5 MAC)

  • 2018: 7-6 (5-3 MAC), L Camellia Bowl

  • 2019: 6-7 (3-5 MAC), L Quick Lane Bowl

  • 2020: 2-4 (MAC-only schedule)

  • 2021: 7-6 (4-4 MAC), L Lending Treen Bowl

  • 2022: 9-4 (5-3 MAC), W Potato Bowl

  • 2023: 6-7 (4-4 MAC), L 68 Ventures Bowl

  • 2024: 5-7 (2-6 MAC)

  • 2025: 4-8 (3-5 MAC)

  • 2026: 4-6 (3-3 MAC)

I think the “Fire Creighton” crowd is understandably working from a knee-jerk reaction that poor-performing D1 football teams don’t have to keep their head coaches if they don’t want to. But aside from the on-field talent, probably the biggest separator between a school like EMU and a typical Power-level school is that EMU’s going to have a much, much more difficult time pulling the trigger on paying a buyout for a fired coach. A school like EMU doesn’t benefit from having an army of millionaire boosters. A school like EMU doesn’t play in a league with an outstanding media rights deal. A school like EMU doesn’t have Purdue money. Or Arizona State money.

Earlier this year, I received a copy of Creighton’s contract details. Here’s what it reads.

Firing Creighton without cause would cost the university 100% of his remaining contract value in base and supplemental pay, which starts at $1,440,000. Assuming that Creighton hasn’t been paid all of his current-year base salary yet, it’s probably closer to the contract’s maximum payout price of $1.5 million.

Creighton’s coming up on the end of the fourth year of his contract, and his annual base pay goes up from $415,000 to $420,000 on July 1, 2027, then up to $425,000 the following summer. Creighton still has a combined $285,000 lined up to receive in supplemental payments next year, and $310,000 in 2028.

Creighton originally signed a new 5-year deal in 2023 after the team’s Potato Bowl win in Idaho, and the contract includes a clause that says if he and EMU reach a bowl game, then that would trigger an automatic one-year extension on his deal. In 2023, EMU finished the regular season 6-6 and made it to the 68 Ventures Bowl to add a sixth year to his contract.

If Creighton can hang onto his seat until at least Nov. 1, 2028, he’ll see a $50,000 retention bonus for being the second coach to stay with the team for 15 seasons.

Mike Piatkowski

It took a while for EMU’s offense to reach a level of competency it was content with, but any improvements made on this side of the ball seem to have vanished in a hurry. Mike Piatkowski, a former quarterback for Creighton at Drake and fourth-year offensive coordinator for the team, hasn’t provided great answers for this team since he took over in 2022, and his offenses haven’t achieved sustained success.

The numbers simply don’t show any reason to think that the offense has gotten better since Piatkowski received the promotion to full-fledged OC in 2023.

Piatkowski’s first stint at EMU was as a graduate assistant from 2016-2018; then he went to Indiana for three years before he returned as EMU’s quarterbacks coach in 2020. He received the title of pass game coordinator in 2021 and 2022, then became Creighton’s OC the following year.

Total Off. Rank

Scoring Off. Rank

Off. SP+ Rank (ESPN)

Off. Available Yds (BCF Toys)

2020

61

33

51

42

2021

78

51

80

57

2022

88

55

66

53

2023

132

120

130

131

2024

75

3

111

79

2025

78

92

113

83

2026*

131*

122*

126*

132*

Pass Off. Rank

Pass Y/A Rank

Rush Off. Rank

Rush Avg. Rank

2020

30

26

104

107

2021

33

66

112

109

2022

76

64

80

97

2023

125

130

114

116

2024

57

96

84

111

2025

61

76

82

67

2026*

97*

136*

130*

122*

Black uniforms

The math is even simpler on this front. It’s time to burn the black uniforms.

Since rolling out the black uniform sets last year, EMU is 2-4 in its black tops (1-2 each season).

  • W, 34-31 vs. Louisiana (2025)

  • L, 28-21 vs. Ohio (2025)

  • L, 31-21 vs. Western Michigan (2025)

  • W, 28-17 vs. Sacramento State

  • L, 34-14 vs. Toledo

  • L, 35-7 vs. Central Michigan (at Ford Field)

Third Down: Things just aren’t the same

Again, I’ve never heard Creighton complain about any of the changes in the MAC or to college football at-large. But the job Creighton took is inherently a different job than the one he has today.

In 2022, EMU’s 3-point loss to Toledo kept EMU from going to the MAC title game because the MAC still recognized East and West divisions at the time. Two years later, the MAC got rid of the divisional splits and changed the way teams qualified for the title game. Instead of EMU needing to be better than five other teams in the West, now the job is to be one of two teams at the top of the 13-team league standings by the end of the regular season (and hopefully tiebreakers work out in your favor, unlike Toledo last year).

The sport’s postseason is different, too. FBS football transitioned from the BCS model to a playoff model that only included four teams in Creighton’s first season at EMU. The playoff grew in 2024, making it a 12-team field, and now, officially official as of yesterday, the CFP will include 24 teams beginning next season.

Making a playoff was never a thought when Creighton first came to EMU, and the fanbase was happy to finally see a team actually make bowl games and come away with one, long-awaited postseason victory in 2022.

But in 2026, the sport’s priorities are simply different. A bowl game might still mean something, but if EMU’s going to remain an FBS-level football team, then this program’s going to have to set its expectations a little bit higher than a backdoor 6-6 finish to go to the, say, Snoop Dogg Arizona Bowl.

Fourth Down: How bad does EMU want to win the MAC?

I don’t have a great answer here, but it’s a question that I have stapled to my cranium. As I think about things I should write in the future to make this a better publication, I’ve come to the realization that I need a central question to hone in on. I cover the wins and losses with this football team, but I don’t think I’ve come any closer to a pretty important question.

How badly does EMU want to win?

How badly does EMU want to win its football games? How badly does EMU want to invest in winning a MAC crown? How important is it for EMU to be in the expanded playoff? How seriously does EMU want to be taken in this sport?

Does EMU want to win badly enough to do something about this football team’s leadership? Or does EMU want to win so badly that it won’t do anything at all?

Read more: Ypsilanti’s college football newsletter!

Reply

Avatar

or to participate