Image via Eastern Michigan Athletics
FINAL SCORE: WMU 34, EMU 27
Just 18 seconds into the game, Eastern Michigan looked like it was in for another embarrassing night.
Down 24 at halftime, it seemed like a big loss was unavoidable.
Once the fourth quarter rolled around, though, the biggest comeback in school history was on the table. A quarterback change, from Jace Stuckey to Brogan McCaughey, led to three straight scoring possessions, and EMU clawed back in the second half of Tuesday night’s rivalry matchup at Western Michigan.
EMU’s defense held WMU running back Jalen Buckley down in the second half and forced the Bronco punt team on the field after there were no punts in the first half. Eastern also stopped committing so many dang penalties in the second half. EMU was flagged 12 times for 140 yards (95 yards at the half) while WMU was penalized five times for 62 yards.
Amareon Blue was probably the most impressive athlete on the field last night. The sophomore running back led the game with 160 rushing yards (long: 41) on 27 carries and three touchdowns, while Buckley, on the other side, had 140 yards (first play of the game: 72 yards) on 20 carries with two tuddies.
Possibilities swung in EMU’s direction after a 31-7 score in WMU’s favor turned into 34-27, and EMU had another last-minute opportunity on offense to pull off a road upset against one of the MAC’s best, but fell 22 yards shy of getting the touchdown it wanted at the end.
EMU watched CMU celebrate with a new trophy at Ford Field earlier in the month, then yesterday it watched WMU dance with the Michigan MAC trophy.
Here’s how Tuesday’s action unfolded:
SCORING SUMMARIES
7-0, WMU (1Q, 14:42) — WMU TD: 72-yard run by Jalen Buckley
One play in, six points on the board for Western Michigan.
Mostly untouched on the run, WMU’s stud running back took the opening handoff all the way across the field for a 72-yard score.
For WMU, this was its third straight game with a 70+ yard rushing score.
14-0, WMU (1Q, 6:12) — WMU TD: Buckley, again, from 1 yard out
Defensive penalties gave WMU 40 yards on the scoring drive.
The first was a defensive pass interference (Caleb Dobbs) when WMU faced third and medium from its own 13-yard line.
Then, on a Broc Lowry run to get WMU across midfield, EMU was penalized for live-ball (holding, Makhi Gilbert) and dead-ball fouls (late hit, Quincy Byas).
Buckley eventually pounded his way in for his second score of the quarter.
14-7, WMU (1Q, 2:32) — EMU TD: Amareon Blue runs 7-yard score after punt muff
EMU’s offense was held to a punt after its second possession, but WMU gave the ball right back.
Daniel Hull’s high punt was misplayed by WMU’s returner deep in their territory, and EMU recovered the loose ball on the 7-yard line.
Technically a new drive in the red zone, EMU scored on just one play: a handoff to Blue that he scored on, his 4th of the year.
17-7, WMU (2Q, 3:23) — WMU FG: Kelly Dieter makes 36-yarder
After both defenses held each other to turnover on downs on EMU’s side of the field, WMU settled for a 36-yard field goal to take a 10-point advantage.
24-7, WMU (2Q, 0:40) — WMU TD: Cole Cabana scores
Cabana of WMU scored at the end of a 5-play, 57-yard drive.
WMU got a little bit of help on the drive with a roughing the passer penalty against Ronn Hardin to move it along 15 yards.
EMU was penalized for 95 yards by the half, which is the most it gave up in a game all year.
31-7, WMU (2Q, 0:02) — WMU TD: Pick six
Stuckey’s third-down throw to Joshua Long was intercepted and returned 50 yards to the house by WMU’s Dillon Moore.
31-13, WMU (3Q, 11:28) — EMU TD: Blue’s second TD for 41 yards
EMU made a change at QB to begin the second half with McCaughey in to replace Stuckey.
McCaughey was 3-for-3 passing for 32 on his first series, and his biggest completion was to Harold Mack along the left sideline on fourth down.
One play later, Blue escaped WMU’s defense and got into the end zone after a 41-yard scamper.
EMU tried to throw on a 2-point play after the touchdown, but McCaughey’s throw was no good.
31-20, WMU (3Q, 5:53) — EMU TD: McCaughey to Long on second straight score
Blue got things started with runs of 18 and 10 yards.
On 2nd & 17, McCaughey completed a risky throw to Deveraux for 30 yards and put EMU in the red zone.
A defensive pass interference call on a throw to Benson Prosper scooted EMU closer, and McCaughey connected with Long in the end zone for the team’s second straight scoring drive.
34-20, WMU (3Q, 5:53) — WMU FG: Kelly, from 27 yards out this time
WMU ate up eight minutes of game clock on a 14-play, 64-yard drive that finished with a 27-yard field goal from Kelly, his second of the night.
Buckley got the last three handoffs of the drive and was halted for no gain on his third-down carry in the red zone.
34-27, WMU (4Q, 7:36) — EMU TD: Hat trick for Blue
Blue, the lightning rod of the night, moved the chains on a fourth-down run near midfield, then McCaughey connected with Deveraux for a 23-yard pickup through the air a couple of plays later.
Freshman tight end Armaad Sharp took a shovel pass to the 2-yard line, and Blue finished the series with a short run at the goal line, his third touchdown of the night.
KEY PLAYS, MOMENTS, TURNOVERS
JACE STUCKEY MAKES FIRST START
Stuckey became the third player to start at quarterback for EMU this season with Noah Kim sidelined for his third straight game.
However, the homegrown talent didn’t finish the game. Stuckey was replaced by McCaughey at halftime and finished the evening with 7 pass yards (6-for-9), as most of his throws were either check-downs behind the line of scrimmage or for a short gain.
Stuckey was lucky to see his first throw of the day not be intercepted. His first pass of the night was targeted over the middle for Nick Devereaux. The pass was tipped and caught by the defense, but a roughing the passer penalty against a couple of D-linemen kept the ball in EMU’s hands for a little while longer. They finished the drive with their first of three first-half punts.
DEFENSIVE STAND IN SECOND QUARTER
WMU had nine, tough rushes from Buckley and Cole Cabana moved WMU across the field and deep into the red zone on its first possession of the second quarter, but EMU’s defense stood tall at the end of the series. Lowry completed his pass on second-and-goal, but Donmiel Rogers dropped WMU receiver Egypt Nelson before he had a chance to score on the play.
After a timeout, Lowry misfired on his throw in the end zone on third down, and linebacker Bryce Eliuk forced an incompletion on fourth down for a turnover on downs at the 3-yard line.
THEN EMU’S OFFENSE STOOD UP ON FOURTH
After getting a defensive turnover on downs, the offense failed to put a serious dent in WMU’s defense on the following drive. From WMU’s 25-yard line, EMU tried to make things happen with a run play out of the Wildcat formation, but WMU’s defense wasn’t tricked by the razzle-dazzle and got the turnover on downs.
WMU’s offense didn’t pick up a first down on the next drive, and settled for a short field goal.
QB BROGAN MCCAUGHEY IN FOR SECOND HALF
Stuckey’s first starting minutes didn’t go so hot, so EMU went back to its backup transfer for help in the second half. McCaughey’s first drive of the night was a successful one: 7 plays, 78 yards, capped by a long scoring run by Blue.
McCaughey would get a passing score on his second drive of the night to make it an 11-point game.
McCaughey found himself in another dramatic scene at the end of the game with less than a minute to go; EMU had the ball in scoring territory, but couldn’t get the touchdown it needed to survive. McCaughey had a 21-yard connection with Long to get across midfield, had his helmet removed on a scramble run opportunity, but was silenced after that.
DEFENSE FORCES WMU TO PUNT IN SECOND HALF
WMU punted zero times in the first half, but twice in the second.
WMU’s first punt was answered with EMU’s second touchdown drive of the third quarter, and the second, midway through the fourth, was also matched with an EMU punt.
FINAL DRIVE FOR NAUGHT
Another dramatic ending with McCaughey at quarterback. This time, on 4th & 7 from Western’s 22-yard line, McCaughey was sacked by a couple of Bronco defenders with 30 seconds left on the clock.
McCaughey led the offense to three straight touchdown drives to begin the second half, but the final two drives finished with a punt and turnover on downs.
INJURIES
Ruled out, of note: QB Noah Kim, LB Barry Manning, DB Jaivian Norman, DB Jason Marshall, DB Caleb Coley, RB Joey Mattord, DL Alijah Lacey, DL Javon Thomas, OL Joshua Anderson, OL Samuel Adjin, OL Cole Powell, TE Tanner Lemaster
In-game exits: OL Tyler Brumfield, OL Elijha Payne
NEXT GAME
After all that, EMU has just one game left on the schedule. Next week, EMU will finish the season with a home matchup against Kent State (3-8, 2-5 MAC).
Kent State lost its final home game yesterday to Miami, 20-3.


